|
MARCH
14, 2005
EDUCATION
Intelligent design vs. evolution in the public schools
STATE
BY STATE
The National Science Teachers
Association maintains a list
of 59 state and local chapters of science teachers.
The Discovery Center for Science and Culture maintains a list
of state-specific intelligent design policies.
IN
THE NORTHEAST
Karl Giberson directs the Forum
on Faith & Science at Gordon College in Wenham, Mass., and is a professor
at Eastern Nazarene College in Quincy, Mass. He has published over a hundred
articles, reviews, and essays and written or co-written four
books: Worlds Apart: The Unholy War Between Science and Religion, Species
of Origins: America's Search for a Creation Story, Oracles of Science:
Celebrity Scientists Versus God and Religion, and Saving Darwin: How
to Be a Christian and Believe in Evolution (2008). His 5th book, The
Anointed: America's Evangelical Experts (with Randall Stephens) is forthcoming
from Harvard University Press. He was the editor-in-chief of both Science
& Theology News and Science & Spirit until 2006. He is critical
of intelligent design theory, charging that it is a religious belief because
the "intelligence" referred to is always God. Giberson has lectured
on science and religion at Oxford University, the Vatican, as well as many American
universities and colleges. Contact 617-847-5702, gibersok@gmail.com.
John Jefferson Davis is a professor of Christian thought at Gordon-Conwell
Theological Seminary in South Hamilton, Mass. Contact via Anne Doll, director
of communications, 978-646-4141, adoll@gcts.edu.
Ron Sala is a Unitarian Universalist minister at the Unitarian Universalist
Society in Stamford, Conn. On the Sunday before Darwin Day 2005 he preached
a sermon titled "The Case For and Against 'Intelligent Design.'" Contact 203-348-0708,
ron.sala@uusis.org.
IN
THE EAST
Anne Clifford is a Catholic nun and associate professor of theology
at Duquesne University in Pittsburgh, Penn. She says what is needed in the current
debate is not the replacement of natural science with theistic science, but
a dialogue between scientists and theologians. Contact 412-396-6530, clifford@duq.edu.
Galen Guengerich is a co-minister at All Souls Unitarian Church in New
York City, where he preached a November
2004 sermon that outlined several concerns, including the teaching of creationism.He
ended with a call for parishioners to pick an issue that mattered most to them,
including science education, and encouraged them to fight back fundamentalism
by fighting for that cause. Contact 212-535-5530, galen@allsoulsnyc.org.
Bertha Spahr is head of the science department at Dover Area High School
in Dover, Pa. She and seven other science educators sent the local board of
education a letter stating they would not abide by the district's ruling to
include intelligent design in the science classroom. Others who signed were
Jennifer Miller, Robert Linker, Robert Eshbach, Leslie Prall, Brian Bahn, David
Taylor and Vickie Davis. Contact 717-292-3671.
IN
THE SOUTHEAST
Michael Ruse
is a professor of philosophy at Florida State University in Tallahassee and
author of Can a Darwinian be a Christian? The Relationship Between Science
and Religion (Cambridge University Press, 2004). He says evolution belongs
in the science classroom while intelligent design can be taken up in the context
of current affairs or history. In his forthcoming book, The Evolution-Creation
Struggle (Harvard University Press, May 2005), he writes that while intelligent
design is infused with religion, some Darwinians have made evolution their religion
by pushing it as a kind of secular humanism. Contact 850-224-6811, mruse@mailer.fsu.edu.
Ben Bridges Sr. is a Republican in the Georgia House of Representatives
who introduced HB 179 in January 2005; it would require the teaching of critiques
of and alternatives to evolution wherever evolution is taught. Contact 404-656-0152,
bbridges@legis.state.ga.us.
Scott Flamand is a biology teacher at Buchholz High School in Gainesville,
Fla., where he led his classes in a two-day Darwin Day celebration that included
student artwork, poetry and viewing of the film Inherit the Wind and
the PBS series Evolution. Contact 352-331-0035, flamans@sbac.edu.
Sara Harding and Nancy Morvillo are professors of religion and biology,
respectively, at Florida Southern College in Lakeland. Together, they are co-directors
of the Florida Center
for Science and Religion, which hosts events designed to engage the central
Florida community in discussions of science and religion. Previous events have
focused on evolution. Contact Harding at 863-680-4185, sharding@flsouthern.edu,
and Morvillo at nmorvillo@flsouthern.edu.
IN
THE SOUTH
The University of Tennessee in Knoxville held its annual Darwin
Day celebration on Feb. 9 and 10, 2005. Contact Mark Cadotte, mcadotte@utk.edu.
Barbara Forrest is a professor of philosophy at Southeastern Louisiana
University in Hammond, La., and co-author of Creationism's
Trojan Horse: The Wedge of Intelligent Design (Oxford University Press,
2004). (Read the first
chapter, posted at TalkReason.org.) She says the debate over intelligent
design and evolution is necessarily a religious, and not a scientific, one because
intelligent design is a religious, not a scientific, belief. She continues that
because intelligent design is an essentially religious viewpoint, it therefore
draws in constitutional questions relating to the separation of church and state,
making it a legal debate as well. Contact 985-549-2109, bforrest@selu.edu.
John Angus Campbell is a professor and director of graduate studies in
the Department of Communication at the University of Memphis and a fellow at
the Discovery Institute. He is co-editor of Darwinism, Design and Public
Education (Michigan State University Press, 2003). Contact via Robert Crowther,
director of communications, Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Culture,
206-292-0401 ext.107, rob@discovery.org.
Niall Shanks is the author of God, the Devil and Darwin: A Critique
of Intelligent Design Theory (Oxford University Press, 2004) and a professor
of philosophy at East Tennessee State University. Contact 423-929-6622, niallshanks@earthlink.net.
IN
THE MIDWEST
Gayle Woloschak is a molecular biologist and a professor of radiology
at Northwestern University in Evanston, Ill. She is director of "The
Epic of Creation," a lecture series that approaches the origins of
the Earth through both scientific and religious perspectives at the Zygon
Center for Religion and Science at the Lutheran School of Theology in Chicago.
Contact 773-256-0670, g-woloschak@northwestern.edu.
Taner Edis
is an assistant professor of physics at Truman State University in Kirksville,
Mo., and co-author of Why Intelligent Design Fails: A Scientific Critique
of the New Creationism (Rutgers University Press, 2004). Contact 660-785-4583,
edis@truman.edu.
Michael Zimmerman is dean of the College of Letters and Science at the
University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh. In 2004, he organized a letter-writing effort
among Wisconsin clergy to ask Grantsburg, Wis., school officials to keep evolution
at the center of the district's science education. The district had earlier
agreed to include alternative theories to be taught, but then reversed itself.
About 200 clergy from Baptist, Catholic, Episcopal, Lutheran, Methodist and
other churches wrote letters to school administrators asking them not to single
out evolution for "special scrutiny." Contact 920-424-1210, mz@uwosh.edu.
Wayne
Cooper, a Missouri state Republican representative, and six co-sponsors
have filed a bill that would compel science teachers to spend equal time on
intelligent design and evolution. Contact 573-751-1119, wayne.cooper@house.mo.gov.
Douglas Rudy is director of Science
Excellence for All Ohioans, a group that supports the teaching of alternatives
to evolution. He says there is no religious content in intelligent design and
believes that both theories can and should be taught in the same classroom.
Contact drudy@sciohio.org.
IN
THE SOUTHWEST
Raymond Arthur Eve is a professor of sociology at the University of Texas
at Arlington. He classifies the current debate as more political than religious,
and has data to show that people's attitudes towards intelligent design and
other manifestations of creationism are strongly predicted by other social attitudes
they hold, such as attitudes toward homosexuals, prayer in school, pornography,
abortion, etc. He is also the co-editor of Chaos, Complexity and Sociology:
Myths, Models, and Theories (Sage Publications, 1997), which examines the
new science of chaos and complexity mathematics that shows how complex systems,
such as the human eye, can evolve from simple mathematical rules without direct
intervention by an intelligent agent. Contact 817-272-2661, eve@uta.edu.
J. Budziszewski is a professor of government and philosophy at the University
of Texas at Austin and a fellow at the Discovery Institute's Center for Science
and Culture. Contact via Robert Crowther, director of communications, Discovery
Institute's Center for Science and Culture, 206-292-0401 ext.107, rob@discovery.org.
Matt Young
is the co-author of Why Intelligent Design Fails: A Scientific Critique of
the New Creationism (Rutgers University Press, 2004). He teaches physics
at the Colorado School of Mines in Golden, Colo. Contact 303-273-3862, mmyoung@mines.edu.
Walt Brown is director of the Center
for Scientific Creation, based in Phoenix, Ariz., and was part of a 1998
panel that advised the local board of education on science standards and evolution.
He has said he does not endorse the teaching of religion in public schools but
is critical of the state's science standards because, he says, they are one-sided
in favor of evolution. Contact 602-955-7663.
IN
THE WEST/NORTHWEST
Paul Chien is a professor of biology at the University of San Francisco, a Jesuit
university, and a senior fellow at the Discovery Institute's Center for Science
and Culture. Contact via Robert Crowther, director of communications, Discovery
Institute's Center for Science and Culture, 206-292-0401 ext.107, rob@discovery.org.
John
Mark Reynolds is an associate professor of philosophy at Biola University,
a Christian university, in La Mirada, Calif., where he is also the founder and
director of the Torrey
Honors Institute. He is also a fellow at the Discovery Institute's Center
for Science and Culture. Contact john@johnmarkreynolds.com.
Richard Weikart is an associate professor of history at California State
University, Stanislaus in Stanislaus, Calif., and a fellow at the Discovery
Institute's Center for Science and Culture. He has lectured on the subject "Does
Darwinism Devalue Human Life?" Contact via Robert Crowther, director
of communications, Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Culture, 206-292-0401
ext.107, rob@discovery.org.
John Schneeberger is with the Bitterroot Human Alliance in Hamilton,
Mont., and has advocated against the inclusion of intelligent design in Darby
public schools. Contact 406-370-3230, schnee@montana.com.
Mark Perakh
is a professor emeritus of physics at California State University, Fullerton.
He is author of Unintelligent Design (Prometheus Books, 2004). Contact
760-751-9932, marperak@cox.net.
|